NEWS
USDA Orders Silence On Mad Cow Disease In Texas

Author: Steve Mitchell
United Press International . (Source)



The U.S. Department of Agriculture has issued an order instructing its inspectors in Texas, where federal mad cow disease testing policies recently were violated, not to talk about the cattle disorder with outside parties, United Press International has learned.

The order, sent May 6 by e-mail from the USDA's Dallas district office, was issued in the wake of the April 27 case at Lone Star Beef in San Angelo, in which a cow displaying signs of a brain disorder was not tested for mad cow disease despite a federal policy to screen all such animals.

The deadly illness also is known as bovine spongiform encephalopathy.

Both the USDA and its Inspector General -- amid allegations that an offsite supervisor overruled the opinion of the inspectors onsite and made the final decision not to test the animal -- have opened up investigations to determine why agency policy was violated.

The order, which was obtained by UPI, was issued by Ijaz Qazi, circuit supervisor for the USDA's Food Safety and Inspection Service's Dallas district, which covers the entire state. It reads: "All BSE inquiries MUST be directed to Congressional Public Affairs Phone 202-720-9113 attention Rob Larew OR Steve Khon. This is an urgent message. Any question contact me. Ijaz Qazi."

Although the language might sound innocuous, experienced inspectors familiar with USDA parlance have taken to referring to the notice as a "gag order."

The National Joint Council of Food Inspection Locals -- the national inspectors union -- considers the order a violation of inspectors' free speech rights and is considering legal action against the USDA for breaching the labor agreement they have with the agency.

Inspectors alleged the order also suggests the agency is concerned about its personnel leaking damaging information about either the Texas case or the USDA's overall mad cow disease surveillance program, which has come under fire since the discovery of an infected cow in Washington state last December.

"Anytime the government suppresses an individual's freedom of speech, that's unconstitutional," Gary Dahl, president of Local 925, the Colorado inspectors union, told UPI.

Stanley Painter, chairman of the National Joint Council, said the USDA has sent out notices in the past stating inspectors cannot talk to reporters.

"It's an intimidation thing," Painter told UPI. Inspectors have the right to talk to anybody about any subject, as long as they clarify they are not speaking on behalf of the USDA and they are not doing it on government time, he said.

USDA spokesman Steven Cohen said he was not familiar with the notice from the Dallas office. He said he would look into it, but did not respond by UPI's publication time. In general, Cohen said, "There's an expectation any statement on behalf of the agency would come from the office of communications (in Washington.)"

Asked if employees could speak freely as long as they clarified that their views did not reflect those of the agency, Cohen said, "We'd rather that agency policy be communicated by those in a position to speak for the agency."

Qazi told UPI the notice was not issued in conjunction with the Texas case and it was routine agency practice that outside inquiries be referred to the Washington office. He said inspectors are free to talk to outside parties, including reporters, and he did not consider the e-mail a violation of the labor agreement with the inspectors.

Painter said the USDA's efforts to keep its employees from talking about mad cow would be better spent "with issues like protecting the consuming public instead of trying to hide things." He added he would "just about bet his last nickel" agency management was attempting to suppress information about the Texas case.

"To keep federal employees from reporting government waste, misuse of appropriations -- those types of things -- that's not a good thing either," Dahl said. "If there is something wrong, let's get it out in the open -- let's get it fixed. We're working for the public, the American consumers. I think they have the right to know this," he said.

"And believe me there's so many indicators saying that the USDA's mad cow testing program is broken," Dahl added.

At least one member of Congress, Sen. Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, agrees.

Harkin, a long-time critic of the USDA, sent a letter to Agriculture Secretary Ann Veneman on Monday, saying the Texas incident "calls into question the effectiveness and reliability of USDA's current and proposed surveillance system."

The USDA has proposed testing more than 200,000 cows -- or 10 times its current rate -- in an expanded program scheduled to begin June 1. Harkin wrote in the five-page letter, however, that given the realities of the cattle industry, it is "quite doubtful" the USDA will be able to test that many cows, particularly because it had difficulty finding 20,000 last year.

"We simply cannot tolerate a BSE testing system that fails to give valid answers to critical questions for U.S. consumers and foreign customers," Harkin said in the letter, which sharply criticizes the agency's failure to address explicitly how its new surveillance program will be implemented.

"We look forward to receiving (Harkin's) letter and having the opportunity to review it and respond to him," USDA spokesman Ed Loyd told UPI. "USDA has acknowledged there was a failure in not testing that cow in Texas for BSE, so we are all working to ensure that does not occur again."

Jim Rogers, a spokesman for USDA's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service, which oversees the agency's mad cow surveillance program, told UPI the agency has tested about 15,500 animals since fiscal year 2004 began, on Oct. 1, 2003. However, the agency has refused to identify the states and facilities from which the cows originated. Rogers said UPI would have to seek that information through the Freedom of Information Act.

The question is central to the USDA's implementation of its expanded surveillance program. Downer cows -- those unable to stand or walk -- made up the bulk of the animals the agency tested for mad cow in previous years, but these were banned from being slaughtered for human consumption in December. This means the agency inspectors no longer can obtain brain samples from these cows at slaughterhouses as they could in the past.

Furthermore, the USDA has not provided any evidence it has worked out agreements with rendering facilities or ranchers, where downers and dead cows are now most likely to be found, to obtain the extra animals for testing.

Loyd said the agency is "working very hard to get animals on the farm that would never show up in a processing facility," and he was "not aware of any issues" that would delay the launch of the new program.

However, he was unable to provide the names or locations of the rendering facilities where the agency will be obtaining cow brains for BSE testing. He said he would look into it but did not return two follow-up phone calls from UPI before publication.



(all) (at) (au) (br) (ca) (ch) (cn) (cu) (dk) (eg) (eu) (gr) (id) (in) (it) (jm) (jp) (ke) (ls) (my) (nz) (tr) (ug) (uk) (us) (vn) (ww) (za) (zm)

(all) () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () ().

Woolworths Acquires Macro Wholefoods

Banned Pesticide Blamed For Fish Mutations

EU Assembly Votes to Ban Toxic Pesticides

Obama's Choice of Vilsack: AgriBusiness as Usual at USDA ?

A Cautious Farm and Food Pick

Top Australian Chefs Unite Against GM Food

Organic Milk is Cream of the Crop

Majority of Darjeeling Tea To Go Organic

Nanotechnology - Sweating The Small Stuff

Government of Canada Invests Nearly $1.3 Million in Canadian Organic Industry

Seeds of Discontent

GM Moratorium Lifted in Two Australian States

Organic and Tastier The Rats Nose Knows

A Speyside Organic Whisky Wins the Supreme Title in the 2007 Scottish Food and Drink Excellence Awards

Work Starts on the National Australian Domestic Organic Standard

Long Island Rooting For Natural Landscaping

No Cloned Animals in Organic Food

Quiet Organic Revolution in South Africa

Nitrogen Testing Could Aid Organic Certification

Soil and Health Association Pleased at Organic Bread Victory

Ten Things the EU has Done for the Ordinary Citizen

Eastern European Countries Jumping on Organic Wagon

Whole Foods Market and Wild Oats Marketplace Announce Merger

USDA in Legal Trouble over Industrial Scale Dairies

USDA Appoints Oregonian to National Organic Standards Board

Genetically Modified Hens Containing Human Genes Lay Cancer Fighting Eggs

The Hunt for Natural Food Colours

How Wal Mart Discovered Organic

Canada Announces National Organic Logo and New Regulations

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission Addresses 'Organic' Claims

Tony Blair Choses Organic Over GM Farming

FAO to Hold International Conference on Organic Agriculture and Food Security in 2007

The Battle of DDT

United States to Fund DDT Spraying in Uganda

WHO Gives Indoor Use of DDT a Clean Bill of Health for Controlling Malaria

Escaped Golf Course Grass Frees Gene Genie

How Wal Mart Discovered Organic

Lesotho: Farmers Overcome Child Malnutrition Through Organic Farming

East Africa: Region Seeks to Harmonise Organic Standards by 2007

Organic Food Goes Mass Market

Wal-Mart Targets the Organic Market

America's Whole Foods Market Expands into the United Kingdom

Organic Road To Riches For Chinas First Lady

15th IFOAM Congress Unites Organic World

Uganda Biggest Exporter of Organic Products in Africa

Italian Organic Standards Join Family of IFOAM Standards

The Australian Organic Industry Unites

Turkey Aligns Organic Farming Rules With European Union

Organic Sector Calls for Strict Liability Under the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety

Making San Diego an Edible City

Revealed: Health Fears Over Secret Study Into GM Food

The International Day for Biological Diversity 22 May 2005

Aussies Accused of Double Standards Regarding GM Food Labelling Because of USA

Soil Atlas of Europe: European Soil Quality Declining

The Legacy of Agent Orange in Vietnam

Food Sovereignty - Turning The Global Food System Around

Australian Scientists Develop Enhanced Crops To Feed The Poor Using Traditional Selective Breeding

Bio What? First Comprehensive Public Perception Study of Biotechnology in South Africa

The Zambia Experiment - GM vs Organic

Results of the First Global Review of Earth's Ecosystems.

Apeda Plans To Introduce Group Organic Certification For Small Farmers

Organic Milk Needs A Pasture

Brazil Says 'Yes' to GM Crops and Stem Cell Research

Biowatch Court Victory to Reveal GM Crops in South Africa

South Africa's Stance on GM Foods

Japan Urges Western Australia to Say No to GMO

Monsanto Agrees To $1.5m GM Crop Bribe Penalty In Indonesia

Australia's GM Free Status a Polite Fiction

Joining Resources To Improve Research In Organic Food and Farming

Report Proves That Organic Farming Is Better For Wildlife

Organic Agriculture in Greece

Wriggly Wonder - Culture of the Good Worm

X Games Skater Flips Over Organic Food

Traditional Rice Varieties Ideal For Organic Farming

Genetically Modified Food Is Heading For Your Fridge

Improving Quality Safety and Costs in the European Organic and Low Input Supply Chain

Vietnam's War Against Agent Orange

Genetically Engineered Salmon More Aggressive

European Action Plan for Organic Food and Farming Adopted

Cuba Is A Potential Organic Produce Provider For The USA

The Green Party of New Zealand Launches The Food Revolution Campaign

United States Agriculture Department Rescinds Changes to Organic Food Standards

Shell Be (Organic) Apples

Bush Administration Threatens to Weaken Organic Program

Australia United States Free Trade Agreement

Stockholm Convention on POPs Becomes International Law. Launching a Global Campaign to Eliminate 12 Hazardous Chemicals

The Gene Revolution: Great Potential for the Poor - But no Panacea

Farming Is Not Like Any Old Business

USDA Orders Silence On Mad Cow Disease In Texas

Seaweed to Clean up DDT Contamination

Monsanto Shelves Its Global Plan for Genetically Modified Wheat

Biotech Foods Keep Coming Despite Monsanto Setback

Toxic Pesticides Above Safe Levels in Many U.S. Residents

Explore The Organic Table With Chateau Laurier And Ottawa Symphony

Top Chefs Serve Up Organic Cuisine To Summer Travellers Across America

NSW Rules Out GM Canola Trial

Fourth New Zealand Organic Food And Wine Festival In Oamaru

Kyoto Protocol on Climate Change Comes Into Force

Kim Wilde and the Pleasures of Gardening

Paying To Be Poisoned UK Pesticide Use

New Zealand Launch Of National Organic Standard

Farm Scale Evaluations Of Spring Sown Genetically Modified Crops

Billboards Milk The GM Debate

The GM Nation Report Findings Of The National Debate Is Published

Denmark Bans Glyphosates, The Active Ingredient In Roundup

The Cartagena Protocol On Biosafety Becomes Law

Brussels Rejects Bid For Ban On GM Crops In Austria

Sixty Four Countries Agree On Sustainable Fishing Practices

ANSI To Assess USDA National Accreditation Process

Little Economic Benefit From GM Crops

Europe Sets Rules For Labelling Genetically Modified Food

The European Union Stance On GMO and WTO

Cartegena Protocol On Biosafety Governing International Trade In GMOs To Become Law

EU Ratifies UN Protocol For Genetically Modified Food

Jamaica Looks To Organic Farming

Cuba Enters Market For Organic Products

USWTO Case Against EU On GM Is Misguided

Opening An Organic Restaurant The Paper Work Jungle

United Nations Commission On Sustainable Development Opens Its 2003 Session

Blair Faces Huge Resistance To His Support For GM Crops

Australian State Of NSW Bans Production Of GM Food Until 2006

Insects Thrive on GM Crops

Organic Food To Fight Cancer

Huge Possibilities For New Zealand Organic Exports - Biofach 2003

Global Precedent For Sustainable Agriculture Set By Australias State Of NSW

Chinas Largest Organic Food Base Setup In Qinghai Tibet

Organic Vegetables On Show In Tasmania

New Zealand Organic Food And Wine Festival In Oamaru Goes National

Natural Selection In Egypt

Chimps Go Ape For Organic Bananas

Kailis Has The Good Oil On Expansion

The Fear Of Food - The World Rejects America

Australian Shoppers Prompt Crackdown On GM Food

Heart Of The Country Working To Live In A Dream

Can Beggars Be Choosers

Requiem Agent Orange

Monsanto Hid Decades of PCB Pollution

Ousted Scientist and the Damning Research into Food Safety

First DDT Ban In United states Takes Effect In 1972

NEWS
HOMEhome pageCERTIFYcertification bodies and logosNEWSthe organic newslineNORANational Organic Registry AustraliaPEOPLEpioneers, supporters, membersBOOKSbooksGLOSSARYdefinitions of various termsADDITIVESadditives and linksPESTICIDESthe dirty dozenGMOgenetically modified organismsWHYwhy organic ?ABOUTconstitution, financial, incorporationCONTACTcontact detailsTRANSLATEtranslationsSEARCHsearch results
? 2009 Organic Ltd (ACN 102 995 344). organic.com.au/news/2004.05.14
RSS Feed Atom Feed RSS Feed